Blog

How Bad Leadership Affects Employee and Team Performance

a woman sitting on a couch
Isabelle Ford
|
Published on:
October 21, 2026

Poor leadership affects employee performance

(TL;DR)
Poor leadership can affect much more than employee morale. It can increase workplace stress and burnout, reduce productivity, and contribute to higher employee turnover. Common signs include poor communication, micromanagement, favouritism, and inconsistent decision-making. If these issues keep appearing across a team, the problem may go beyond individual employee performance. Repeated leadership behaviours can shape how employees communicate, respond to pressure, and work together. For HR and senior leaders, spotting these patterns can help them understand what is affecting team performance and make lasting improvements.

Some teams do well while others struggle, even when they have similar skills, resources, and opportunities. Often, the difference comes down to leadership.

‍

Good leadership can help a team stay focused and make progress, while bad leadership can slow even a highly capable team down. That’s why it’s important to understand how poor leadership can affect team performance.

‍

Poor leadership can cause more than frustration. A 2013 meta-analysis by Schyns and Schilling in The Leadership Quarterly has linked it with negative outcomes such as lower employee well-being and individual performance, as well as higher turnover intentions and counterproductive work behaviour. These problems can affect productivity, workplace culture, and employee retention across the organization.

The Link Between Leadership and Team Performance

Research shows that leadership plays a major role in how well a team performs. Gallup's 2015 research reports that managers account for at least 70% of the differences in employee engagement.

‍

When leadership is weak, team members may:

‍

  • Lose the motivation to put in extra effort.
  • Start to wonder if their work and contributions really matter.
  • Feel unsure about their goals and what they should focus on.

‍

These issues can lead to a series of interconnected problems. Even a strong team may begin to struggle with deadlines, teamwork, and solving problems effectively.

‍

Poor leadership affects employees first, but its effects can spread across the wider team and organization. 

Signs of Poor Leadership

Some common signs of poor leadership include:

‍

  • Lack of communication: Employees don’t receive clear instructions, updates, or feedback, which can lead to confusion and mistakes.
  • Micromanagement: Leaders closely control employees' work instead of trusting them, which can reduce confidence and motivation.
  • Favouritism and bias: Some employees receive better treatment or opportunities, making others feel overlooked or treated unfairly.
  • Inconsistent decision-making: Leaders frequently change their decisions or apply rules differently, so the employees are unsure about what is expected.

The Effects of Poor Leadership Behaviour on Employees 

1. Reduced Employee Morale

Poor leadership can quickly lower employee morale. When managers rarely recognize good work, dismiss employee concerns, or constantly focus on mistakes, employees may start to feel that their efforts don't matter.

‍

This can make employees less interested in taking initiative or going beyond their basic responsibilities. They may also become less confident about sharing ideas because they expect their manager to ignore or criticize them.

‍

This creates a team where people do only what is required rather than actively contributing to its success. Employees may still complete their tasks but their motivation and sense of ownership can decline.

‍

For HR and senior leaders: If morale is declining, look beyond engagement scores or individual employee performance. Pay attention to patterns such as reduced initiative, fewer ideas being shared, lower participation in meetings, or employees doing only what is required.

‍

These may indicate that leadership behaviour is affecting how safe, valued, or motivated employees feel. Gather feedback from employees and managers, look for recurring patterns across the team, and address the underlying leadership behaviours rather than treating low morale as an employee motivation problem. 

2. Increased Stress and Burnout

Bad leadership can turn normal workplace pressure into ongoing stress. Leaders who constantly change priorities or fail to provide clear direction can make it difficult for employees to know what is expected of them.

‍

Employees may feel that they always have to be available, fix problems caused by unclear decisions, or work longer hours to keep up.

‍

When this pressure continues without enough support or recovery time, it can contribute to exhaustion and burnout.

‍

The effects can go beyond feeling tired. Employees may find it harder to concentrate, become less engaged with their work, or feel emotionally drained before the workday even begins.

‍

As more employees experience these problems, the team's performance can suffer through missed deadlines, mistakes, and reduced energy.

‍

For HR and senior leaders: Repeated stress and burnout should not automatically be treated as individual employee resilience issues. Look at whether leadership behaviours are contributing to the pressure.

‍

Constantly changing priorities, unclear expectations, excessive availability demands, or a lack of support can create unnecessary strain across a team.

‍

If these patterns appear repeatedly, examine how leaders are setting expectations, communicating changes, and responding to workload concerns. 

3. Poor Collaboration

Healthy collaboration depends on trust, communication, and psychological safety. Poor leadership can weaken all three. For example, when a manager plays favourites, encourages competition between employees, or blames individuals when something goes wrong, team members may become less willing to work openly with one another.

‍

Employees can start protecting their own work instead of helping their colleagues. They may hesitate to ask for help, share information, or offer different opinions because they are worried about being blamed or judged.

‍

This creates communication gaps and makes simple tasks harder to complete. Instead of solving problems together, employees may work in isolation, duplicate each other's efforts, or avoid difficult conversations.

‍

For HR and senior leaders: When collaboration starts breaking down, look at what employees may be responding to.

‍

Are people reluctant to speak up?

Are teams withholding information?

Are disagreements becoming personal?

Are employees avoiding asking their manager for help?

‍

These patterns can indicate a lack of trust or psychological safety linked to leadership behaviour. Rather than addressing each conflict separately, look for recurring behaviours or relational dynamics that may be creating the problem. 

4. Decline in Productivity

Poor leadership can reduce productivity even when employees are working hard. The problem is not a lack of effort; it is a lack of direction. 

‍

When leaders fail to provide the resources employees need, they spend more time trying to understand what they should be doing instead of doing the work itself.

‍

For example, an employee may spend hours completing a task only to discover that their manager wanted something different. If this happens repeatedly, employees may become frustrated and stop taking initiative. They may also focus on avoiding mistakes rather than finding faster or better ways to work.

‍

For HR and senior leaders: A drop in productivity doesn’t always mean employees need more accountability. First, examine whether leadership behaviour is creating unnecessary friction. Excessive supervision or delayed decisions can make it harder for employees to do their work efficiently.

‍

Look for patterns across the team before assuming the problem is individual performance, and consider whether leaders need to change how they communicate, delegate, or make decisions. 

5. High Turnover Rates

One of the most visible effects of poor leadership is increased employee turnover. Employees may tolerate a difficult manager for a period of time, but ongoing criticism, excessive pressure, and poor communication can make staying in the role increasingly difficult.

‍

When employees believe that their concerns won’t be heard or that their working conditions are unlikely to improve, they may begin looking for opportunities elsewhere. In some cases, strong employees leave first because they have more options available to them.

‍

High turnover then creates another problem for the remaining team. They may have to take on additional responsibilities while new employees are recruited and trained. This can increase workload and create even more stress.

‍

The result can become a cycle: poor leadership contributes to employee dissatisfaction, dissatisfied employees leave, and the increased pressure on the remaining team creates further performance problems.

‍

For HR and senior leaders: When turnover is concentrated around a particular manager or team, look beyond exit interviews and replacement costs. Look for patterns in how employees experience that leader, including communication, recognition, workload, trust, and opportunities to speak openly.

‍

If multiple employees leave for similar reasons, the issue is not isolated dissatisfaction; it reflects a recurring leadership pattern that needs to be addressed. 

How Spellcast Can Help

The effects of poor leadership often point to a deeper issue: repeated patterns in how a leader behaves, communicates, and relates to others.

‍

For me, this understanding was shaped in part by witnessing the same senior leader repeatedly struggle with the people who worked under them. 

‍

Instructions would change mid-project, expectations would become contradictory, and employees were often blamed for problems that had been created by the leadership itself.

‍

Despite multiple employees raising concerns, the pattern continued, with one person after another left the role.

‍

Experiences like this highlight why individual incidents are often not enough. When the same behaviours repeatedly affect different people, the deeper patterns behind those behaviours need to be understood.

‍

Spellcast addresses this challenge with Vestra Framework™, a five-phase approach designed to help senior leaders like that understand and change the behavioural patterns behind leadership challenges.

‍

The process begins with Discovery, understanding how a leader currently operates, followed by Identification of behavioural patterns and relational dynamics.

‍

Through Attention, leaders become more aware of these patterns in real situations. Disruption then focuses on interrupting automatic behaviours, while Habituation helps make new behaviours more natural and sustainable.

‍

If poor leadership is affecting employee morale or retention, the first step is to understand the behaviour behind the problem.

‍

Book a Clarity Session to identify the patterns that may be affecting your team’s trust, morale, and performance.

‍

Frequently Asked Questions

Which leadership style is most effective in performance improvement?

Transformational leadership is often considered one of the most effective styles for improving performance. It gives people a clear sense of purpose while encouraging ownership, development, and continuous improvement. However, the most effective approach depends on the team, the situation, and the organization’s goals.

How does HR raise a behaviour concern with a senior leader?

HR should raise the concern privately and objectively, using specific examples of the leader’s behaviour and its impact on team performance. The conversation should focus on observable patterns rather than personal criticism, clarify the expected behaviour, and agree on appropriate next steps. 

What are common leadership mistakes?

Common leadership mistakes often come down to how leaders communicate and support their teams. A leader may fail to set clear expectations, avoid difficult conversations, micromanage employees, or give little feedback and recognition. Poor decision-making and resistance to change can also make it harder for a team to perform and grow. 

How does bad leadership affect employee mental health? 

Poor leadership can contribute to workplace stress and emotional strain, particularly when employees experience excessive demands, lack of support, or fear of criticism. Over time, these conditions may affect well-being, engagement, and the ability to recover from work-related stress. 

Author Bio

Isabelle Ford helps leaders and organizations understand the behavioural patterns that influence leadership effectiveness, workplace relationships, and organizational performance. Through her behaviour-focused approach, she supports leaders in creating more intentional and sustainable change.

‍

With more than 20 years of experience working inside banks, government departments, and enterprise organizations, Isabelle brings an insider perspective to her work in leadership development, behavioural transformation, and organizational consulting.

‍

Dossier content
A close-up of a vibrant green plant with broad leaves, set against a neutral background. The leaves have a glossy texture and are arranged in a rosette pattern, showcasing the natural beauty of the plant.

Not sure where to start?

The Clarity Session is 90 minutes to get a direct read on what is actually getting in the way — and what to do about it. This is not a sales conversation. It is the work.

A close-up of a vibrant purple flower with multiple petals, surrounded by green leaves. The flower has a delicate texture and a rich color, standing out against the greenery in the natural environment.A scenic view of a mountain landscape with a clear blue sky. The foreground features green grass and a tranquil body of water reflecting the surrounding mountains.